Copyright Office opens comment on disc backups, computer playback and public domain films
Six of the 10 new proposals in the 2027 DMCA rulemaking cover films and video on disc or online. Supporters’ comments are due December 7, 2026.
By 2020 Movie Reviews Team ·
In short
- The U.S. Copyright Office published its proposals for the 2027 cycle of DMCA exemptions on October 28, 2026. Six of the 10 proposed classes cover audiovisual works.
- They include personal copies of damaged discs, disc playback on computers with no licensed player, and copying public domain films from discs.
- The Register intends to recommend renewing every current exemption except one for medical device repair, including those used by filmmakers, teachers and libraries.
- The notice recalls that the Register has repeatedly turned down format-shifting and computer-playback requests in earlier cycles.
- Supporters’ comments are due December 7, 2026, opponents’ comments February 22, 2027, and replies March 22, 2027.
On Wednesday, October 28, the U.S. Copyright Office published the list of proposals it will weigh in the 2027 cycle of exemptions to the Digital Millennium Copyright Act’s ban on breaking the digital locks that control access to copyrighted works. Six of the ten proposed classes concern films and other video on DVD, Blu-ray, Ultra HD Blu-ray or online, from personal copies of damaged discs to copying public domain films. The first round of comments is due December 7.
The ban is section 1201 of Title 17 of the U.S. Code, the copyright law. Every three years the Librarian of Congress, on the recommendation of the Register of Copyrights, can exempt particular classes of works where the ban is getting in the way of noninfringing uses. The current exemptions took effect on October 28, 2024, for three years. This is the tenth such rulemaking, and the exemptions it renews would run from October 2027 to October 2030.
The six film proposals
| Class | What it would allow | What the notice says about past cycles |
|---|---|---|
| 1: Accessibility and captioning | Libraries and other public entities could unlock video on websites and apps to add captions and audio description | Today’s captioning exemption covers only disability services offices at educational institutions |
| 2: Criticism and comment | The current exemption for clips from DVDs, Blu-rays and streamed video would extend to Ultra HD Blu-ray and to commercial uses | The records in 2018 and 2021 did not support adding Ultra HD Blu-ray’s AACS2 protection |
| 3: Playback on unsupported devices | Owners could play DVD, Blu-ray and Ultra HD Blu-ray discs on a personal computer that has no licensed player | The Register recommended against similar requests in 2000, 2003, 2006, 2010 and 2015 |
| 4: Replacement | Personal copies of damaged or deteriorating discs, copies when playback hardware is disappearing, and copies when a digital service shuts down | The Register has repeatedly declined space- and format-shifting exemptions |
| 5: Personal playback | Skipping or muting parts of a disc during private home playback, citing the Family Movie Act of 2005 | A new request; the Office asks whether filtering is possible without breaking the lock |
| 6: Public domain works | Copying public domain films from discs that also carry copyrighted material, when no fairly priced equivalent is available | Similar public domain requests were declined in 2003, 2010 and 2012 |
By our count, 10 of the 12 petitions behind these six classes were filed by individuals rather than organizations. Several of the Class 4 petitions describe owners who want to keep films watchable when a disc starts to fail, when players become hard to find, or when a service that supplied digital copies shuts down. One petition says the supply of used players for some formats is “finite, non-replenishing,” and the Class 6 petition points to the growing number of works entering the public domain since 2019.
Film exemptions set for renewal
The Office received 43 renewal petitions and found meaningful opposition to only one, the exemption for medical device repair, which it will now treat as a new proposal. The Register intends to recommend renewing every other existing exemption as it stands. For films, that covers clips used in documentaries and other films, noncommercial videos, nonfiction multimedia e-books, college and K-12 teaching, online courses, and media literacy programs run by libraries, museums and other nonprofits, as well as captioning and audio description by disability services offices, preservation and replacement copies made by libraries, archives and museums, and text and data mining by university researchers.
The online-course petition gives a sense of how far these exemptions reach: it cites a History of Hollywood course that offers close readings of classics such as King Kong and Casablanca and has reached almost 80,000 students. Among the film exemptions, the only objection came from the Entertainment Software Association, the Motion Picture Association and the Recording Industry Association of America, and it was to an attempt to reword the noncommercial video exemption. The Office agreed that a rewording would amount to an expansion, so only the current wording is up for renewal.
Where disc collectors stand now
None of the current film exemptions covers copying a disc you own for backup or for playback on another device. The closest is the library exemption adopted in 2021. It lets eligible libraries, archives and museums replace damaged or deteriorating discs when the film is not reasonably available to buy or stream. The Register found that its supporters had not shown that copying a disc before it deteriorates is fair use. The Library Copyright Alliance, which asked for its renewal, says many films in its member libraries’ collections “are unavailable for purchase or streaming.” The new notice asks whether personal, rather than institutional, preservation changes that analysis. Nothing changes until the Librarian issues a final rule, which would take effect in October 2027.
How to comment
Supporters of a proposed exemption, and anyone who neither supports nor opposes one, have until December 7, 2026. Opponents follow by February 22, 2027, and supporters reply by March 22, 2027. Comments go through Regulations.gov, with a separate comment for each class. Short comments are limited to 5,000 characters, and longer filings to 25 pages per class. The petitions themselves are posted on the Copyright Office’s 2027 rulemaking page.
This article explains a proposed rule and is not legal advice. Whether a particular use of a disc is lawful depends on the facts and on the exemptions in force.
Sources
- Exemptions To Permit Circumvention of Access Controls on Copyrighted Works (notice of proposed rulemaking, 91 FR 67788) U.S. Copyright Office, Library of Congress (Federal Register, via govinfo.gov), October 28, 2026
- Tenth Triennial Section 1201 Proceeding, 2027 Cycle U.S. Copyright Office, October 28, 2026
- U.S. Copyright Office Issues Notice of Proposed Rulemaking in the Tenth Triennial Proceeding Under Section 1201 (NewsNet Issue No. 1097) U.S. Copyright Office, October 28, 2026
- Exemption to Prohibition on Circumvention of Copyright Protection Systems for Access Control Technologies (final rule, 89 FR 85437) Library of Congress, U.S. Copyright Office (Federal Register, via govinfo.gov), October 28, 2024
Researched and drafted with AI assistance, then checked against the 4 sources above in a separate fact-check on October 31, 2026. Spotted an error? Tell us.